War Poetry

 War Poetry

Thinking Activity

This blog is a part of thinking activity about the War Poetry assigned by Vaidehi Haryani Mam.

 The difference of all the War Poets is given below : 

Response : 

1.wilfred Owen

2. Rupert Brooke

3. Wilfrid Wilson Gibson

4. Siegfried Sassoon

5. Ivor gurney 

Where it has a differences among the mentioned War Poets:

The war poetry presented here reflects a range of perspectives and experiences from different poets during times of conflict. Wilfred Owen's "Dulce et Decorum Est" and Wilfrid Wilson Gibson's "The Fear" depict the harsh realities and horrors of war, highlighting the physical and psychological toll it takes on soldiers. Owen's poem exposes the brutality and disillusionment of combat, challenging the glorification of war with its condemnation of the "old Lie." Gibson's poem captures the fear and uncertainty felt by soldiers, particularly in the face of death. 

In contrast, Rupert Brooke's "The Soldier" and Siegfried Sassoon's "The Hero" convey a more romanticized and patriotic view of war, emphasizing themes of sacrifice and national pride. Brooke's poem portrays a sense of honor and duty associated with dying for one's country, while Sassoon's poem explores the disillusionment and cynicism behind the front of heroism. 

Ivor Gurney's "The Target" offers a more introspective perspective, reflecting on the moral complexities and personal reflections of a soldier facing the possibility of killing an enemy combatant. Overall, these war poems vary in their portrayal of war, from the grim realities to the idealized notions of heroism and sacrifice, providing insight into the diverse experiences and emotions of those involved in conflict.

Question : Compare any two poems concerning the subject, style of writing, and patriotism.

Response : 

These two poems offer contrasting perspectives on war, particularly regarding the portrayal of patriotism and the style of writing. In "The Hero" by Siegfried Sassoon, patriotism is depicted through the lens of societal expectations and glorification of sacrifice. The poem portrays a mother's pride in her son's death for his country, despite the harsh reality of his demise being a result of panic and fear rather than heroism. The style of writing in "The Hero" is more structured and formal, with a narrative that conveys a sense of detachment and irony, highlighting the disillusionment with conventional notions of heroism and patriotism.

On the other hand, "The Target" by Ivor Gurney presents a more introspective and somber perspective on war. The poem explores the moral complexities and emotional turmoil experienced by a soldier who has taken another's life in combat. Gurney's portrayal of patriotism is less overt, focusing instead on the personal struggle and inner conflict faced by the speaker. The style of writing in "The Target" is more introspective and reflective, with a stream-of-consciousness narrative that conveys the internal turmoil and moral ambiguity of war.

Overall, while both poems touch upon themes of war and patriotism, they offer contrasting perspectives and styles of writing. "The Hero" reflects on societal expectations and the disillusionment with conventional notions of heroism, while "The Target" delves into the moral complexities and emotional toll of war from a more introspective viewpoint.

Question : Do you find any such regional poem/movies/web series/songs that can be compared to any one of the poems Also, give a proper explanation of the similarity. the poem The Hero with Border movie.

Response : 

 Comparision :  "The Hero" by Siegfried Sassoon to the Bollywood movie "Border," released in 1997.

"The Hero" by Siegfried Sassoon portrays the disillusionment with conventional notions of heroism and patriotism, highlighting the stark contrast between societal expectations and the harsh realities of war. Similarly, "Border" is a war drama based on the true story of the Battle of Longe wala during the Indo-Pakistani War of 1971.

In both "The Hero" and "Border," there is a portrayal of patriotism and heroism that goes beyond traditional glorification. While society may view the soldiers as heroes for their actions, both the poem and the movie shed light on the human cost of war and the internal conflicts faced by the characters.

In "Border," the characters grapple with the challenges of war, including fear, loss, and sacrifice. The film depicts the bravery and valor of the Indian soldiers defending their country against Pakistani forces, but it also delves into the personal struggles and moral dilemmas faced by the characters.

Furthermore, both "The Hero" and "Border" employ a narrative style that conveys a sense of detachment and irony, highlighting the disillusionment with societal expectations and the sobering truth behind the facade of heroism. They offer a critical perspective on the complexities of patriotism and the sacrifices made in the name of national duty.

Overall, the similarities between "The Hero" and "Border" lie in their exploration of patriotism, heroism, and the human cost of war, as well as their nuanced portrayal of the internal conflicts and moral dilemmas faced by individuals in times of conflict. Both works challenge simplistic narratives of heroism and sacrifice, presenting a more nuanced and introspective examination of the realities of war.

Thank You for Visiting.